Boogie! Samba! Shuffle?
I remember watching Sonic Shuffle through development and kept thinking:
"Er, I dunno..." "Well actually, it does kinda look cool..." "But then, it's kind of weird."
"Hey, I guess it'll be alright." I was never quite sure what to make of it with each successive
surge of information, and now that I've actually played the game, I still don't know. Some
things I like and some things really bug me.
The obvious comparison with Mario Party has to be made, and frankly, at
this point, Shuffle isn't stacking up favorably. Party's star feature, obviously, is in its
four-player mini games. Running around the board is, well, boring. It was never much of an
issue though, because there was a guaranteed mini-game at the end of all four players' turns.
In Shuffle, the only time you get a mini-game is when you actually land on a mini-game
square. And even then, it may not always be a "Mini Game"...sometimes it will be a "Mini Event",
stupid little sequences for one player that have various effects. Consequently, the majority of
gameplay is spent running around the board. That's bad thing #1.
Bad thing #2: ironically, the card feature is both Shuffle's most unique
aspect and also its biggest drag. You have a hand of six cards: the number on the card you
decide to play is the number of spaces you move. You can choose your direction, but you
must move the full amount of spaces...no stopping short. That harmless-sounding flaw
could just turn out to be the game's death knell. In the one game I played with my siblings, we
spent more time just trying to play the proper mathematical arrangements of cards to land on the
right spaces than anything else. (Unlike Mario Party, where merely passing the Star space would
earn you a chance at the prize, you actually have to land on the Precioustone space in
Shuffle.) It's kind of cool at first, because it seems like you have to use some level of
strategy, but by the third Precioustone we were sick of skipping back and forth trying
desperately to land on one blasted square.
As if these issues didn't slow the game down enough already, Shuffle boasts
what are the most ungodly load times I have yet witnessed on Dreamcast. The board has a load,
every mini-game has a load, exiting the mini-game has a load, special events have loads... And
once again, the longer you play, the worse it seems to get.
At some points, we found ourselves ignoring the Precioustones altogether and
simply aiming for the mini game squares. The games themselves are extremely cool, and easily
Shuffle's best feature: tossing characters around in a frying pan, playing a giant lumbering
around trying to squish your opponents (who in turn are running around trying to blast you down
with bazookas), a game of real Sonic "Labyrinth"... They're hilarious to see and even
funner to play. It's a real bummer that more emphasis wasn't placed on these than on the
questionable "board" elements of the game.
Another thing that really sucks is that, in order to unlock the extra stuff,
you have to be playing the one-player Story mode. The four-player Versus match is just
that: a match. When it's over, the game restarts and that's that. No Rings for the collection
pool, no extra characters unlocked... If I was barely able to put up with the tedium of a
four-player match, I can't imagine how I'm going to fare going off against some lame-ass
computer opponents.
There are some additional features I haven't really touched on, like the
semi-cool Forcejewels and the slight changes in the board layout that occur over extended
playtime... But they were mostly unnecessary superficialities that further serve to complicate
what's already a game that's far too complex for its own good.
My first impression, I'm sad to say, is not too favorable. I'll keep going and
see what happens, but I fear that Sonic's triumphant rebirth in Sonic Adventure could
just prove to lead to a brand new era of cash-in shame. Let us pray. Perhaps you'll be
inspired to say your prayers after grabbing a couple eyes full of the latest
Cool Team Swag.
-- Green Gibbon!
"I see." -- Ryo Hazuki
(Shenmue [a number of people suggested this one...])
You can blame this page on Jared "Green
Gibbon!" Matte. The GHZ isn't affiliated in any way with
Sonic Team, but how we wish we were. Hosting provided by
SonicNEXT and VGHQ.
|